Windows 10: Convenience of using W10 without MS store?

  1. Posts : 167
    Windows 7 Ultimate 64
       23 Apr 2015 #1

    Convenience of using W10 without MS store?

    This is speculative, but what do people see the impact of the Win10 store being upon people's engagement with 3rd party software?

    And what attitude will MS adopt concerning quality testing for software that's offered through their store app?

    With game sales, some retailers like Steam don't apply their own quality testing to updates that developers push through to their customers, but other retailers, like Origin, and GoG, do go through their own quality test process, and it results in patches being slower to get applied through their services compared to Steam - which regularly upsets customers for a variety of reasons (waiting on bug-fixes or new features, simple impatience, appearance of favouritism).

    If W10 run no independent quality test, it's possible that some malicious software could get delivered to large numbers of customers, who hypothetically might accuse MS of not protecting them, and as being responsible for whatever damages are experienced on their end.

    And MS' Games For Windows Live garnered a very disfavourable reputation among gamers that resulted in developers shunning the service, even leading to some of them removing GFWL from their games retroactively to satisfy gamers' pleas. A poor gamer reception and engagement level led to MS claiming to be shutting down their GFWL service, which caused gamers to become upset that they would no longer have access to gaming software which they'd paid for.

    MS later rescinded their decision to shutter their service - but the situation crafts a question of dependability regarding MS server-hosted 3rd-part app software, and where it leaves customers if a publisher stops selling a piece of software on the MS store. When it comes to games no longer sold on Valve's Steam service, the games remain available for download to owners who purchased the game while it was still being sold.

    What are the intentions of people here, regarding uptake of the MS store as a resource to access new software?
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  2.    23 Apr 2015 #2

    It will highly depend on what they will offer. If they do an additional product assurance and make sure that no malware or other PUPs are being delivered, then I would use it. But if it is just a copy of what is available from the owner site, then it would have little value added.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  3.    24 Apr 2015 #3

    I doubt I would use it for desktop software, would prefer to go to the website and download myself

    Been through this when I was an Apple user, and extra restrictions placed on anything from the store (not sure if MS would do the same)

    If you buy from the website, install it and backup your download then it is there to re install whenever you want, even if a new version comes out
    Downloading from the store you only get the latest version, so if you need to do a reinstall you can only get the latest, which might require purchasing again if you have an older version

    store apps like the ones in win 8 I don't mind, desktop style apps I would not get from the store
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  4.    24 Apr 2015 #4

    It's something I briefly brushed on HERE, where I said "... I also have very little trust that Microsoft are carrying out sufficient checks on what they allow in their store and get the impression they just want quantity over quality at any cost. It’s a mess. And to make things worse, because they’re supposed to be vetting apps, it gives consumers a false sense of security when installing them."

    I don't like this trend of apps requiring permissions to access things like location, calendar, contacts, camera, microphone, etc. even though there is no apparent reason for them to do so and is one reason I don't install third-party apps. There needs to be more detailed information/transparency before installing.

    Now, I fully understand with traditional desktop software once you allow a piece of software admin privileges it can do whatever it wants on your computer, however with normal PC software not only do people like myself only install from reputable software companies (unlike 'apps' where a lot of them are from unheard-of developers with little accountability), but I also have firewall whitelisting and only software that has a legitimate reason to connect to the internet gets whitelisted (which outside Microsoft/Sysinternals software is only Ebay Turbo Lister and Canon DPP for lens data downloads).

    If normal Windows desktop software was accessing peoples location, calendar, contacts, microphone, etc. without a good reason people would be boycott that software pretty much immediately, but with 'apps' they seem rather blasé about it, which I think is due to consumers having a false sense of security with 'apps'.

    So, in conclusion, if Adobe for example were to release software through Windows store that had full functionality of normal desktop software, didn't want to scrape my contacts list, etc. then sure I'd buy from there (presuming I have the option to buy it outright, rather than be forced into a subscription). However, third-party apps with limited functionality, that doesn't solve a problem, from an unknown developer, that want's full access to personal information... Uhm, why would I do that?
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  5.    24 Apr 2015 #5

    I'll never use the Store.
    I turned the Store off (disabled) for all users but still haven't got it removed from the start menu...reg edit comes next.
    Next I need to get rid of more Win10 programs that will be a deal breaker if I can't rid the system of them (separate post later next week).

      My ComputerSystem Spec

  6.    24 Apr 2015 #6

    For me I use the store to get board games and news. Do I need it.. no but it has it's advantages for me at least.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  7.    24 Apr 2015 #7

    Delicieuxz said: View Post
    This is speculative, but what do people see the impact of the Win10 store being upon people's engagement with 3rd party software?

    And what attitude will MS adopt concerning quality testing for software that's offered through their store app?
    There's no reason to guess, all this is already in place for Windows 8, and the rules and regulations are already there for app developers. As far as quality goes, Apps must go through a rigorous security scan, which is automated.. so it's not impossible for something to pass through this scan, but Store apps are already running in a sandbox which gives them very little damage they can cause anyways. Of course, social engineering is something you can't scan for.

    As for revoking apps, or what not.. I think this entire model Is still in flux... and will change over time.
      My ComputerSystem Spec


Related Threads
Solved How to reinstall Store. in Software and Apps
Well, it is a continuing issue. Over last two updates, I faced some issues with the metro apps. After the updates, some apps fail to work. Previously, when I installed the 10159 upgrade, some apps did not respond for the first time. I got the...
My PC email and my Xbox email are different and I don't want to make a whole new account on my PC for this to work. I'm on build 10240. Sorry if this a confusing lol. So when I go to the store on my pc and download one of the games that say Xbox...
Windows Store in Software and Apps
Installed preview 10147 and having trouble dowloading from Windows Store. Anything I try I get "Something happened in our end" "Try again later" Tried both Pro and Home versions (x86)
Solved Store, Store (beta), and apps in Software and Apps
For the past few days, I've been wrestling with Store (beta) issues. It worked, it didn't work, it sort of worked..... When it worked, it offered 10 updates to apps update all did not work, so I updated them individually by hitting the down...
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

© Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 21:41.
Find Us