Windows 10: Do I need Both Win 10's File History and Win 7's Backup?

  1.    18 Jan 2018 #1

    Do I need Both Win 10's File History and Win 7's Backup?


    I have them both, and I'm beginning to get faith in indexing and I wonder if I need to keep the Windows 7's back up regime.

    The only problem I have with indexing is it seems to keep getting bigger and bigger and bigger - and I don't know what to do.

    My entire data drive*(E) is ~ 100Gigs, yet my file history drive is almost 300Gigs.

    *I have a SSD for programs (C), and one data drive E, and one partitioned removable drive F & H
    Data drive E is backed up by File History to H on my removable drive.
    My Win 7 Back up of E goes to F on my removable drive

    So my issue is:
    If you had a choice to make would you keep File History, or Windows 7's back up system?
    And why is my file history getting so large?

    Thanks in advance...
      My ComputerSystem Spec


  2. Posts : 5,507
    10 Home x64 (1709) (10 Pro on 2nd pc)
       18 Jan 2018 #2

    chuckiechan said: View Post
    My entire data drive*(E) is ~ 100Gigs, yet my file history drive is almost 300Gigs. ... why is my file history getting so large?
    That is normal. File History keeps multiple different versions of your documents from different dates. You can manage how much history you want it to keep.

    Delete Older Versions of File History in Windows 10

    Change how Long to Keep File History in Windows 10


    If you had a choice to make would you keep File History, or Windows 7's back up system?
    To be honest, the more types of backups you keep the better. It isn't really an 'either/or' choice - you can use both. You can never have too many backups

    'Backup and Restore (Windows 7)' is a deprecated feature in the Fall Creators Update. It may be removed in later versions of Windows 10.

    Microsoft said:
    System Image Backup (SIB) Solution
    We recommend that users use full-disk backup solutions from other vendors.
    Features removed or Deprecated in Windows 10 Fall Creators Update

    There are better solutions to the two functions Backup and Restore provides, backing up your files and making a system image to restore a working system to your disk , should it fail or become corrupted. Most here recommend Macrium Reflect (free).
      My ComputersSystem Spec


  3. Posts : 108
    windows 10 Home ver 1709
       18 Jan 2018 #3

    +1 for Macrium
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  4.    19 Jan 2018 #4

    chuckiechan said: View Post
    If you had a choice to make would you keep File History, or Windows 7's back up system?
    Without a doubt File History. If you delete some file and backup your system the deleted file will not be there.

    If you deleted all your tax records 2 years ago where will they be? In your latest backup (Windows 7 style or Macrium)? Nope they will not.

    They will be in your backup from 2 years ago (assuming you remembered when you deleted them and restored the correct backup). Alternatively you can just flick back in time through File History until you find them and the fact it was 26 months not 24 doesn't matter.

    Both would be the best answer but given a choice, File History. It is trivial to reinstall Windows and only takes 20 minutes.

    Just make sure your file History drive isn't permanently connected so if you get ransomeware it isn't corrupted too.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  5.    19 Jan 2018 #5

    lx07 said: View Post
    Without a doubt File History. If you delete some file and backup your system the deleted file will not be there.

    If you deleted all your tax records 2 years ago where will they be? In your latest backup (Windows 7 style or Macrium)? Nope they will not.

    They will be in your backup from 2 years ago (assuming you remembered when you deleted them and restored the correct backup). Alternatively you can just flick back in time through File History until you find them and the fact it was 26 months not 24 doesn't matter.

    Both would be the best answer but given a choice, File History. It is trivial to reinstall Windows and only takes 20 minutes.

    Just make sure your file History drive isn't permanently connected so if you get ransomeware it isn't corrupted too.
    I try to keep my back up drive unplugged, but do you know of a way it could be disabled in device manager, and started up automatically only when it's time to back up when the computer is idle, and the chance of getting ransom ware remote (since no one is operating the computer).

    And thanks to all for the advice. I'll probably dump Win 7 back up, remove the partition and dedicate the drive to File History but shorten the retention period if it heads for a Tetrabyte.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  6.    19 Jan 2018 #6

    "...but do you know of a way it could be disabled in device manager, and started up automatically..." You have to both disable and re-enable said divice within device manager. I know of no automatic software way to re-enable that external device.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  7.    19 Jan 2018 #7

    RolandJS said: View Post
    "...but do you know of a way it could be disabled in device manager, and started up automatically..." You have to both disable and re-enable said divice within device manager. I know of no automatic software way to re-enable that external device.
    I'm sure if it was easy and effective, someone would have done it!
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  8.    19 Jan 2018 #8

    chuckiechan said: View Post
    I'm sure if it was easy and effective, someone would have done it!
    Better to physically disconnect - anything you can do programmatically so, potentially, could malware. File History will store changes and flush them to backup disk automatically when you connect it.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  9.    19 Jan 2018 #9

    lx07 said: View Post
    Better to physically disconnect - anything you can do programmatically so, potentially, could malware. File History will store changes and flush them to backup disk automatically when you connect it.
    one more question. If I used Win 7 to make a system image (C drive), will I be able to load it using Win 10?

    Btw, I have no data on the C drive, only the O/S and programs, so this should be the entire image, with data backed up by File History. That is my new plan.
      My ComputerSystem Spec


 

Related Threads
Solved Backup using File History in Backup and Restore
Does File History (Libraries) Backups utilize the time schedule I created for Automatic Backups?
Hello, I'm trying to backup my files using File History onto an external hard drive. The problem is, it claims "Windows is backing up your files for the first time," but it doesn't copy anything at all! In the "New" settings panel, when I...
File History Backup Options in Backup and Restore
Hi, I have a two part question. First, I turned on File History the first of the month, set the 'Back up my files' to daily and it now reports that the last backup was on 5/9/2016, about a week after I set it up, and viewing the data seems to...
I've been using Backup & Restore on some Win 7 systems but now I have added a new Win 10 PC (from HP). It's not entirely clear to me why I would use the Win 10 File History facility versus Win 7 Backup & Restore. File History looks like a...
Using Goodsync - 2 evenings wasted trying to fix File History - no more
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:30.
Find Us