Any Windows program to connect to a remote LINUX GUI


  1. Posts : 11,247
    Windows / Linux : Arch Linux
       #1

    Any Windows program to connect to a remote LINUX GUI


    Hi Windows GURUS

    Is there any sensible program that can connect to a remote Linux machine showing its GUI (Windowed) desktop - I've head things like vnc can do it -- any ideas though.

    What I want is as shown in the following example - OK this is Linux to Linux but you should get the idea of what I want to do (On the Linux machine Host -have krdc and krfb installed (on KDE desktop I'm using). On the remote Linux machine have at least krfb installed - I'd install krdc as well so you can check both ways.

    Then using the krdc app with vnc selected you are logged on to your remote machine - even showing a VMWare XP VM running on the Linux desktop too.

    Any Windows program to connect to a remote LINUX GUI-screenshot_20200925_095736.png

    selecting RDP also logs on to Windows remote machines (multi concurrent sessions too if you want )

    So what I need is now Windows to remote Linux -- every time I try I just get a blank screen for the remote machine.

    Cheers
    jimbo
      My Computer


  2. Posts : 17,661
    Windows 10 Pro
       #2

    See if this video could give you some tips:



    Video is from Part Six in this tutorial: RDC - Connect Remotely to your Windows 10 PC

    Kari
      My Computer


  3. Posts : 11,247
    Windows / Linux : Arch Linux
    Thread Starter
       #3

    Kari said:
    See if this video could give you some tips:



    Video is from Part Six in this tutorial: RDC - Connect Remotely to your Windows 10 PC

    Kari
    Hi there
    Thanks I tried that -- still just get Green login screen asks for user name and password - and then just get blank (green) screen -- protocol is shown as vnc

    I suspect that as the vnc connection works for Linux to Linux there's nothing wrong with the vnc servers on those systems (or the clients) so I think I'll have to look at some vnc servers and clients for Windows tiger / tight vnc could be good one --I've some spare Windows VM's i can test this with so it doesnt matter if I completetly trash the system !!

    The linux systems are easily reachable via command line from windows via ssh command -- the ssh -X (logon to GUI) doesn't work - but that's known because xorg is the protocol used from windows but a lot of distros (including mine) now don't use xorg any more for the X-server (the thing than displays the GUI) but wayland so there could be an inherent problem with full screen GUI connections to Linux.

    For servers that's fine - who really needs a GUI on a dedicated server but for accessing a desktop type installation you really need the GUI and access to the desktop applications !!.

    Got plenty of time now to experiment --won't be going anywhere for a while -- seems we now have local lockdown here after people have been going bonkers partying in bars etc etc -- same as elsewhere now I guess Just as we thought we'd escaped all the horrors seen elsewhere.

    Keep safe everyone - especially now as summer ends and colder / wetter weather starts arriving.

    again @Kari -- I've done more research and the problem is definitely related to the wayland X-server being used rather than xorg -- red hat distros e.g centos can run a sort of "xorg" compatability mode so the tutorial works.

    I'd suggest perhaps in modyfying the tutorial once the wayland problems have been sorted out !!!

    For info - running 3 linux boxes 2 X arch linux with KDE desktop and standard kernel 5.8.10 and 1 X leading edge development RAWHIDE rel 34 with kernel 5.9.0 fc6 . The arch boxes should work - not bothered about the fedora one as it's "alpha" and "experimental".

    For Windows running Windows 10 20H2 and the insider preview build both on W10 pro for workstations.

    Cheers
    jimbo
      My Computer


  4. Posts : 11,247
    Windows / Linux : Arch Linux
    Thread Starter
       #4

    Hi there @Kari again

    there doesn't seem to be a way on this planet of making this work at all -- at least in my case.!!

    From Windows here's the linux the login screen - the dropdown has about 4 options of session types e.g xorg, vnc etc etc but none of them work - just the green blank scheen after login

    Any Windows program to connect to a remote LINUX GUI-xrdp.png

    I've decided to go for what to some might be a crazy way - but it works.

    On the Windows box I've created a tiny LINUX VM with just enough components for VNC , krfb, krdc and freerdp.
    Now I use the linux VM to get full desktop access to the remote systems as shown in screenshot below.

    The VM uses so little resources even on a modest laptop so that's my choice now.

    Here's what the Linux VM (running on a Windows Host) gives from the Windows desktop when accessing remote Linux

    Working perfectly !!

    Any Windows program to connect to a remote LINUX GUI-screenshot_20200926_082059.png


    I'm not experienced enough to tinker around with Windows to get stuff like this working - but I can mess around with linux systems.

    It's definitely though the wayland server that's the problem -- the native Windows login (ist screenshot) login works to a CENTOS VM (CENTOS 7) but that's really old now and is 100% xorg based.

    Sometimes as an Engineer rather than a "Pure Scientist" you go with "what works" even though it might not be the best or most elegant solution -- I'll leave that to others to find a pure Windows solution.

    Cheers
    jimbo
    Last edited by jimbo45; 26 Sep 2020 at 03:27. Reason: clarified explantation a bit I hope
      My Computer


 

  Related Discussions
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

© Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:49.
Find Us




Windows 10 Forums