New
#20
That's pretty much what I think, also. MS will be flexible up front but not forever. There will be some kind of agreement between the "upgrader" and "MS" to get as many of the boxes in this world onto 10 as possible. They are not going to tell people who have put $$$ and sweat into home brew machines to go stick it where the sun don't shine!
I'm still sticking to my Motherboard theory..... when the heart is ripped out or otherwise stops ticking, end of license.
OEM or Homebuilt is really not the issue. All the machines I have running here with the exception of an old IBM Workstation with XP on it, used as a test machine, are home built. I buy the parts, including a motherboard, which has a MAC number on it (in it), and then buy an O/S, Win 8.1 Pro which is tied to the MAC number. Change the mobo and that MAC stays with the old board.
An Oem license is tied to that old MAC number. The number is supposed to be unique?
You put a new Mobo, with a new MAC, into your machine, try to activate, and MS says sorry cowboy, that number has been used.
With a retail license the new board will be activated even with the new MAC number.
Your HP machine has a MAC number (like a VIN number) so when you accept the upgrade to Win10 the number becomes attached to Win10. ......for life of the device. If it dies tomorrow... life over! You can get another machine (or a new mobo, we don't know yet) and still get a free upgrade to Win10 if you hurry and get it done with the one year period beginning with the release date of Win10. After the year period expires you will have to buy a copy of Win10 in addition to fixing/replacing your machine.
pheww...... I THINK!
Does that make any sense?
OK, as I said, I didn't know how the license is tied to the motherboard; I just figured it was, and you've confirmed what I thought. I just didn't understand the mobo has the Mac number. Apples are still apples in this case.
Yes, that's exactly my understanding. Change OEM to Mac number and you still get apples.
At that point, whether I have an actual OEM or Self-Built machine,it will immediately be labeled (for all intents and purposes) an OEM machine.For the life of that(OEM)machine with its Mac number, Windows 10 gets updates and everything else that comes with the OS.
For the most part, yes. However, if my HP dies with Windows 10 on it, Windows 10 dies. So does Windows 8.1, which is an OEM license. If you replace the mobo, you get a new Mac number; thus, the Windows 8.1 OEM license is no longer valid; you'd have to get another copy.
If I got another machine, I'd be sure to get one with Windows 10 on it. I'm pretty sure the market will be full of Windows 10 computers as soon as Win 10 goes RTM. Although there may be Windows 8.1 machines out there, I don't really see a reason to get one of those because they probably won't be priced lower than a Win 10 machine because there would be a free upgrade to Windows 10 available.
You and I may be able to build our own machines, but not everyone can. I got lucky some years back with a "Build or Buy" SIG in our Computer group. I learned . . .
You've said what I said, although in a different way. We're still on the same page. :)
It's going to be interesting with downloadable O/Ss. If you find a legal copy of Win7 for $50 or so it may be possible to save a few bucks by installing Win7 and upgrading. Depends on the price that Win10 is issued at???
Me thinks a lot of online sellers/stores will have an inventory of Win7 and Win8 on hand when Win10 hits. MS won't want them back (WAG) so we may be knee deep in D/L type with a valid key @ 2 for a quarter???
Time will tell............. I'm gonna round up a quarter just in case!