Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
  1.    17 Feb 2016 #11
    Join Date : Jun 2014
    Posts : 5,548
    Windows 10 Pro

    One day Seagate is facing a class action lawsuit, the next day they're #1. I thought for sure it would be WD.
      My ComputerSystem Spec
  2.    17 Feb 2016 #12
    Join Date : Jul 2015
    Posts : 78
    Windows

    I still wouldn't trust Seagate, I had the 3TB external one and that failed in a 2 year period as well. I have hitachi's too and those are probably like 10 years old and still going strong.

    My theory is all hard drives will fail and it's a matter of when, each is a time bomb. Some just have shorter fuses than others.
      My ComputerSystem Spec
  3.    17 Feb 2016 #13
    Join Date : Aug 2015
    Maine
    Posts : 40,111
    Windows10Pro 64Bit

    I Still agree with most of you guys, I would only buy WD drives, but I only prefer their High end models. I still don't trust Seagate.
      My ComputersSystem Spec
  4.    17 Feb 2016 #14
    Join Date : Aug 2015
    Posts : 85
    windows10 pro

    Quote Originally Posted by TheZeeMan View Post
    Lol they do all of their drives in colors. The green ones are the environment friendly ones. Actually this is new...I'm almost positive its the green ones now:



    I also found their new disclaimer:



    These are the exact drives I'm using in it: Amazon.com: WD AV-GP 2 TB AV Video Hard Drive: 3.5 Inch, SATA II, 64 MB Cache - WD20EURS: Electronics
    not sure if there relation or not
    but for one green drive is intended for low power (green power)
    WD make it to park-head after 8secs idling, which some people find it rather not good (you can disable it with WDidle)
    whether that often park-head causing early wear or not, we cant be sure

    the one you bought are AV (audio video) series, rather than normal green drive
    but i believe the different most likely just firmware that tuned for AV, while parts wise (hardware) is same to normal green drives

    @davidhk
    for desktop drive, u want at least BLUE, for faster performance (7200rpm)

    but for me, if money not issue/consideration, pick BLACK instead BLUE
    longer warranty (5years vs 2years) might not help much, as when hdd fail we lose our data anyway and WD warrranty not cover it
    but based my experience, BLACK series seems using better parts compared to BLUE/GREEN series
    so far i dont have any issue with BLACK HDD except it a bit warmer

    or if you intend for storage purpose (NAS), pick RED series, there is RED PRO if u need better quality one
    (RED PRO is replacing WD RE [sata] enterprise series imo)
    RED drive specification-wise similar to green drive
    but wd claims its ok for 24/7 usage and its been tested for NAS environment also longer warranty (3years)

    while i am not sure RED - GREEN drive is not just about firmware+label different
    but based review so far, seems RED drive more reliable than GREEN...
    i havent hear many failure in RED drive

    but again none HDD fail-prove ... more over traditional hdd have/use moving parts
    so always backup important data
    and for me, replace HDD after 27000hours (3years) of usage
      My ComputerSystem Spec
  5.    17 Feb 2016 #15
    Join Date : Nov 2015
    Posts : 4,891
    windows 10 Home threshold2

    @slyphnier,

    I still have no idea what the heck is blue or black. :-)

    I have a 1TB WD Passport Ultra.
    Is that blue or black ?
    I know, it is a cheap model.
    Or have I totally misunderstood this whole thread ?
      My ComputerSystem Spec
  6.    18 Feb 2016 #16
    Join Date : Jul 2015
    Posts : 78
    Windows

    Quote Originally Posted by slyphnier View Post
    not sure if there relation or not
    but for one green drive is intended for low power (green power)
    WD make it to park-head after 8secs idling, which some people find it rather not good (you can disable it with WDidle)
    whether that often park-head causing early wear or not, we cant be sure

    the one you bought are AV (audio video) series, rather than normal green drive
    but i believe the different most likely just firmware that tuned for AV, while parts wise (hardware) is same to normal green drives
    Correct, at the time I bought the storage array, I need 8 of them and WD green were the cheapest. As I work with audio/video I need all the storage. The raid controller I have actually keeps the drives active so I'm not sure if that's why they died, but nevertheless they fall under a 3 yr warranty period.

    Quote Originally Posted by davidhk View Post
    @slyphnier,

    I still have no idea what the heck is blue or black. :-)

    I have a 1TB WD Passport Ultra.
    Is that blue or black ?
    I know, it is a cheap model.
    Or have I totally misunderstood this whole thread ?
    LOL No worries! I believe the passport uses the 2.5" blue drive but I'm not sure...it should have a 3 yr warranty? As mentioned, the black series are the top of the line with a 5 year warranty. I now buy hard drives based on warranties. For external drives, I recently went with a Toshiba as they offer a 3 yr warranty while Seagate offers 1 and WD offers 2 years on certain drives.
      My ComputerSystem Spec
  7.    18 Feb 2016 #17
    Join Date : Aug 2015
    Posts : 85
    windows10 pro

    Quote Originally Posted by davidhk View Post
    @slyphnier,

    I still have no idea what the heck is blue or black. :-)

    I have a 1TB WD Passport Ultra.
    Is that blue or black ?
    I know, it is a cheap model.
    Or have I totally misunderstood this whole thread ?
    BLACK-BLUE-GREEN-RED-PURPLE is just series do differentiate their internal hdd product
    you can read more on their web Hard Drives, Network Drives, Media Players | Western Digital (WD)

    for their external hdd model, i think mostly using GREEN drive, especially back years ago before RED series come out
    EDIT: quick look on internet, passport ultra seems using BLUE drives

    you can check what hdd used in your external hdd using hdd-smart-tools like crystaldiskinfo i think
    and match the model-code listed to
      My ComputerSystem Spec
  8.    18 Feb 2016 #18
    Join Date : Feb 2016
    Gladstone QLD
    Posts : 20
    Windows 10 Build 10586 x64

    I would say it's their green ones, I have a storage array I put together that has 8 of them of in it and 3 failed within the past 2 years.
    Some not all of them. I still have a 500GB and 2TB one from 2010 and 2014.

    This makes me laugh as I remember days when hard disks often failed. Even telatively poor one by modern standars are far more reliable than some years ago.

    Any 'old boy' knows to make image backups regularly to protect against hdd failure!
    Remember the HGST Deathstar? Now that is what I call one of the baddest Hard Drives I ever seen.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

 
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12


Similar Threads
Thread Forum
Corrupted hard drives
Hi I am sure this has been covered elsewhere but I can't find it. My external drives were set to 'turn off write-cache' and we had a black out. The result is a 3 Tb Seagate external drive, a 2 Tb Seagate external drive, and a 500 Gb portable...
Drivers and Hardware
Having 2 hard drives
Does anyone here have 2 HDDs or 2 SSDs that they use one for the soul purpose of the OS and use the other for installing software? I'm highly considering that. Is that possible in Win10?
Software and Apps
Solved Are all SSD Hard Drives created equal?
Hi everyone. Getting ready to move from Win 7-64 to Win 10-64 when 10 is available next month. It's my understanding that Win 10 will not install over Win 7 so I'd like to install a new 250Gb SSD (I currently have Win 7 on a 128Gb SSD as C: ) for a...
Drivers and Hardware
ssd hard drives not found in win 10
Hey all Have just spent 3 day's trying to install win 10 update (from win 7). I have now been able to do it but had to reinstall win 7 to a standard hard drive I am trying to clone it to my ssd drive now My problem is I have 2 sets of...
Drivers and Hardware
hard drives.
my question is if you are using more than 1 hard drive in your computer I run 3 ops on 3 different drives. when you down load the new win 10 can you install on any drive in your computer? or only the one you signed up for the new down load from...
Drivers and Hardware
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 00:41.
Find Us
Twitter Facebook Google+ Ten Forums iOS App Ten Forums Android App



Windows 10 Forums