New
#1
IMO, MS need to offer both experiences, the 8 and the new way
With 10 they are doing the same thing they did with 8, making a drastic change from one way of doing things to another
8 neglected the desktop side and made the focal point the start screen
10 is neglecting the metro side and making everything desktop oriented
From what I have seen of screen shots the 8 experience is gone, its going to be start menu for desktop and a bigger start menu for tablets (both just on the desktop)
for me its not just a case of start menu v start screen, it should be 8 experience v new 10 experience