Windows 10: Discuss the uses of 'registry cleaners', 'disk cleaners', 'optimizers'

Page 5 of 7 FirstFirst ... 34567 LastLast

  1. Posts : 21,960
    Triple boot - Win 10 Pro, Win 10 Pro Insider (2) - (and a sprinkling of VMs)
       08 Jun 2016 #41

    BunnyJ said: View Post
    I don't see anyone here starting any argument or requiring a warning like that. This is a thread that's allowed to morph into a discussion on the merit of registry cleaning.. this occurs in many threads here. And by allowing this to stay in the current forum it will give members a good idea of the merits of a registry cleaner.. if there are any.

    My take is that a registry cleaner is not needed and hasn't been of any use since WIn95/98. From the articles and evidence that's out on the Web by many there is no proof that a registry cleaner has any affect on the performance of a PC. While cleaning up a few dead entries in the registry data base might feel good it's not needed.

    Jeff..
    BunnyJ said: View Post
    I would never tell anyone not to use a registry cleaner like CCleaner. For me I never used one for reasons already stated. But if someone does use one I recommend that a backup of the system and/or the registry is a must just in case something does go wrong.
    I don't see any arguments either, or anything requiring a warning. Maybe you did, and I missed it. Don't know what "like that" refers to. Morphing is just another way of saying "go off topic".

    If you've never used one (registry cleaner), what experience are you basing your opinions on? There are Web articles and sites to backup the pros or cons of any subject. Common sense and rational decisions are all that really matter.

    No disrespect intended, but I still have not seen any comments posted by the OP. Nor any problems/issues that would have prompted him to open this in a help thread. Only that he wanted to give others a place to talk about it. If he's not going to comment in his own thread, why is it here?
      My ComputersSystem Spec


  2. Posts : 1,648
    Microsoft Windows 10 Home
       08 Jun 2016 #42

    Mystere said: View Post
    As long as you stick to general cleanup tasks, like emptying temporary files or internet files, sure. But as soon as you go into the more advanced cleanup, you start taking more risks.

    Microsoft doesn't recommend ccleaner at all. for example:

    http://news.thewindowsclub.com/micro...isagree-80369/
    CCleaner does not and did not give any sort of issue after windows 7 preview build 7000, at least for me. Whatever advanced operation it may be, it is always safe.

    I personally have tried almost all of the known cleaners. All are problematic other than CCleaner. Their problem is, they want to perform/outperform, they want to clean and free up more space than the others, it makes them aggressive, and the aggressiveness kills some necessary system files. In many a cases those files are impossible to recreate without either hacking the system resources or a complete clean install.

    In the prevailing situation, if anybody can cause a system damage using ccleaner, they can cause a similar damage using the windows explorer too. IMHO that is an user level issue, not program level.

    If the user knows what he is actually doing, and if his cleaner keeps him aware about what it is going to do, then he can use any cleaner safely. After a number of bitter experiences, I learned how to use TuneUp Utilities and used it successfully for next few years. But I never recommended it to anybody, because I dont know for whom the above two conditions will be fulfilled.
      My ComputerSystem Spec


  3. Posts : 21,960
    Triple boot - Win 10 Pro, Win 10 Pro Insider (2) - (and a sprinkling of VMs)
       08 Jun 2016 #43

    Arc said: View Post
    CCleaner does not and did not give any sort of issue after windows 7 preview build 7000, at least for me. Whatever advanced operation it may be, it is always safe.

    I personally have tried almost all of the known cleaners. All are problematic other than CCleaner. Their problem is, they want to perform/outperform, they want to clean and free up more space than the others, it makes them aggressive, and the aggressiveness kills some necessary system files. In many a cases those files are impossible to recreate without either hacking the system resources or a complete clean install.

    In the prevailing situation, if anybody can cause a system damage using ccleaner, they can cause a similar damage using the windows explorer too. IMHO that is an user level issue, not program level.

    If the user knows what he is actually doing, and if his cleaner keeps him aware about what it is going to do, then he can use any cleaner safely. After a number of bitter experiences, I learned how to use TuneUp Utilities and used it successfully for next few years. But I never recommended it to anybody, because I dont know for whom the above two conditions will be fulfilled.
    It really does boil down to experience and common sense. As far as The Windows Club, they have a vested interest in publishing articles and excerpts that will help promote products from their ad base, and cast a dim light on others. They are not Microsoft.
      My ComputersSystem Spec


  4. Posts : 824
    Win10/64 Pro 1511 (and 2 Win 7/64 Ult & Pro systems)
       08 Jun 2016 #44

    derekimo said: View Post
    You don't need any of those programs, I don't even use Ccleaner anymore. If I was going to use one Ccleaner would be the only one.

    Driver programs are usually more trouble than good in my opinion.

    Most of those other utilities are snake oil.
    +1
    Although this M$ KB article predates Win10, the concept remains valid.

    JMHO and EOD for me,

    MM
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  5.    08 Jun 2016 #45

    f14tomcat said: View Post
    I don't see any arguments either, or anything requiring a warning. Maybe you did, and I missed it. Don't know what "like that" refers to. Morphing is just another way of saying "go off topic".

    If you've never used one (registry cleaner), what experience are you basing your opinions on? There are Web articles and sites to backup the pros or cons of any subject. Common sense and rational decisions are all that really matter.

    No disrespect intended, but I still have not seen any comments posted by the OP. Nor any problems/issues that would have prompted him to open this in a help thread. Only that he wanted to give others a place to talk about it. If he's not going to comment in his own thread, why is it here?
    Why not here?? It's a good a place as any.

    I have studied registry's and what they are and how to work with them and what a registry cleaner is good for or not. And from all of that work/reacherch I have found that there is no evidence that supports registry cleaners having any benefit to a PC. I don't use them because of this study I found no reason to.

    Evidence ..
    Are registry cleaners necessary? - Windows Help

    The Windows* registry is a database that lists all of the configuration settings that determine how Windows looks and behaves. Sometimes, settings that are no longer needed will remain in the registry in case they're ever needed again. There's nothing unusual about this, and this data is small in size.

    Some products available for free on the Internet suggest the registry needs regular maintenance or cleaning. Although a registry setting can become corrupt on occasion, in general, the registry is self-sufficient. If you decide to install a registry cleaner, be sure to research the product and only download and install programs from software publishers that you trust.
    Why Using a Registry Cleaner Wont Speed Up Your PC or Fix Crashes
    The Reality

    In reality, registry entries aren’t a drag on your computer’s performance. The registry is a massive database containing hundreds of thousands of entries and individual registry entries are fairly tiny. Even removing a few thousand entries won’t make an appreciable dent in the size of your registry.

    Now, if our computers only had a tiny amount of memory or an extremely slow hard disk, there could be some value to shrinking the registry a bit. But this will be completely unnoticeable on computers in use today. We don’t live in the days of Windows 95 anymore. The Windows registry has also become more robust as Windows itself evolved from Windows 95 to Windows 7 and 8.
    I know some feel that by using one will help their PC and they have had zero issues by using one. That's fine and they can use them but I want to see a fair and balanced discussion on this topic. New users have the right to see both sides and make up their own mind on what to do or use on their PC.
      My ComputerSystem Spec


  6. Posts : 14,995
    Microsoft Windows 10 Pro 64-bit 14393, Windows 10 Insider Fast Ring, Windows 8.1 Update, Ubuntu
       08 Jun 2016 #46

    BunnyJ said: View Post
    Why not here?? It's a good a place as any.

    I have studied registry's and what they are and how to work with them and what a registry cleaner is good for or not. And from all of that work/reacherch I have found that there is no evidence that supports registry cleaners having any benefit to a PC. I don't use them because of this study I found no reason to.

    Evidence ..
    Are registry cleaners necessary? - Windows Help



    Why Using a Registry Cleaner Wont Speed Up Your PC or Fix Crashes


    I know some feel that by using one will help their PC and they have had zero issues by using one. That's fine and they can use them but I want to see a fair and balanced discussion on this topic. New users have the right to see both sides and make up their own mind on what to do or use on their PC.
    I guess you could say, If it makes the user feel good....

    Even manually deleting something from the registry using search can nuke your system, as there are shared .dll's(libraries) in the WinSxs portion of the registry, and if you delete the link.... ***poof*** you just killed 3 or 4 programs if not Windows(ntdll.dll for example).

    That's why if I remove an old program manually, I only do the ones in [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE] and [HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE].
      My ComputersSystem Spec

  7.    08 Jun 2016 #47

    Cliff S said: View Post
    I guess you could say, If it makes the user feel good....

    Even manually deleting something from the registry using search can nuke your system, as there are shared .dll's(libraries) in the WinSxs portion of the registry, and if you delete the link.... ***poof*** you just killed 3 or 4 programs if not Windows(ntdll.dll for example).

    That's why if I remove an old program manually, I only do the ones in [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE] and [HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE].

    I agree. What I like to do when deleting a program is to use this: Download Revo Uninstaller Freeware - Free and Full Download - Uninstall software, remove programs, solve uninstall problems

    It removes more than the Windows uninstaller and it can clean up registry entries. Oh and you can set how aggressive you want the clean up to be.
      My ComputerSystem Spec


  8. Posts : 1,648
    Microsoft Windows 10 Home
       08 Jun 2016 #48

    +1 for Revo Uninstaller. It is one of the programs that I always install immediately after a clean install. It deals with the registry perfectly; but still it makes a restore point before uninstalling a program.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  9.    08 Jun 2016 #49

    f14tomcat said: View Post

    No disrespect intended, but I still have not seen any comments posted by the OP. Nor any problems/issues that would have prompted him to open this in a help thread. Only that he wanted to give others a place to talk about it. If he's not going to comment in his own thread, why is it here?
    It's a discussion, when it get's out of hand or stops being a discussion we'll take the appropriate action.

    A lot of threads take on a life of their own, even after the OP has got their answer or had their problem solved, that's why we don't lock solved threads, the fact this OP hasn't returned is not a reason to close it in itself.

    It is in this section because it fits here.

    Carry on...
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  10.    08 Jun 2016 #50

    f14tomcat said: View Post
    It really does boil down to experience and common sense. As far as The Windows Club, they have a vested interest in publishing articles and excerpts that will help promote products from their ad base, and cast a dim light on others. They are not Microsoft.
    The article was in reference to a Video produced by Microsoft, where the quotes originate.
      My ComputerSystem Spec


 
Page 5 of 7 FirstFirst ... 34567 LastLast

Related Threads
Read more:http://news.softpedia.com/news/are-registry-cleaners-still-needed-on-windows-10-microsoft-says-they-re-not-498103.shtml
Source: Cleaners ought to be clean (and clear) | Microsoft Malware Protection Center
I have encountered several problems re. upgrade to W10. 1) Cannot get Chrome to function at all, which was my preferred browser before W10 (using Win7 and upgrade to 8.1). 2) Edge seems incompatible with Lastpass. So it is inconvenient to look...
Still no update found.. 1/23/2015 Time: 8:30AM US Eastern.. I'll keep looking and if anyone finds it post here please. TIA Jeff :)
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:34.
Find Us