New
#1
Win10x64 1803: Full Format of Hard Drives Faulty?
A few days back I got a slew of disk errors in Event Viewer and quickly backed up the drive in question and started testing it. Before that, I checked and the only errors in the SMART data were crc errors, which do not normally indicate a failing drive, especially in the absence of other errors.
Using the drive manufacturer's utility when booting from a pendrive:
-I tested the disk surface and found 1 bad sector and quite a few slow-read spots.
-I performed a write-erase.
-I then tested the disk again with various tools. All good.
-I quick-formatted the drive with a utility and tested again. For hours. All good.
-I then formatted the drive using Disk Management and selected a full format.
-The drive then miserably failed all testing right off the bat.
This made me think I had botched the repairs and/or had a truly faulty drive, since a full format is supposed to test for and mark bad sectors and ready the disk for use.
Not one to give up, I repeated the above process with a variety of very similar tools. Each time, all testing goes fine if I do not perform a full format using Disk Management. Raw, with no partition, partitioned but not formatted, or quick-formatted, surface reads and writes are as flawless as a normal drive gets unless I use a full format. Hmmm.
Since I have another drive of the same make, model, and purchase date, used in the same machine, I decided to back it up and test it, fearing the worst. Note that this drive had shown no errors of any kind, ever. Initial testing was flawless. After a write-erase and full reformat, the exact same issue has appeared: full formats lead to countless bad sectors.
I do not have a final conclusion at this juncture. I have the two drives (quick format only) now hooked up and operating, reporting good SMART data and passing tests, and no disk read errors showing up in Event Viewer. However, I thought I might share this experience to see what others might have to say, and if indeed there is something botched in this release of Windows 10, give a heads-up. I'll post more as new data comes in.