Windows 10: USB direct connect HDD slower than over network !!! Solved

  1.    06 Feb 2018 #1

    USB direct connect HDD slower than over network !!!


    Hi there

    can anybody explain this :

    HDD (USB3) connected to computer and then copy files from NAS is giving me speed of around 110 MB/s (440 Mb/s) - computer connected via a network switch to NAS

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	hdd.png 
Views:	13 
Size:	20.0 KB 
ID:	175862

    USB3 connected DIRECTLY to NAS is giving about 60 - 70 MB/s

    Not sure why Network would be quicker than local connect.

    Configuration Windows PC LAN ---Switch --->Netgear Nighthawk wifi to router
    NAS -->Switch (LAN) -->Netgrear Nighthawk extender wifi to router,

    The nighthawk is connected to the switch via LAN cable. Wifi for accessing Internet from Nighthawk extender to router (5GHZ)

    HDD is USB3 passport 2 TB self powered drive.

    Anybody got ideas -- not complaining but seems intuitive that a Network connection would be slower than USB3 direct connect. Switch is a 1Gb/s netgear 5 port switch.

    the wonders of Windows Networking I suppose. !!!!

    Cheers
    jimbo
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  2.    06 Feb 2018 #2

    What NAS do you have?

    Just from speculation, I think it could be:
    - Hardware, drivers, and/or OS were optimized for network performance and the manufacturer just cheaped out on the USB hardware/software stack
    - The filesystem driver on the NAS is significantly slower than the one on Windows. If you're using NTFS on that drive and the NAS is using a Linux-based OS then there is an expected slowdown due to the open-source NTFS driver.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  3.    06 Feb 2018 #3

    Hi there

    Thanks

    Using NTFS directly on Linux isn't a good idea -- no probs with Network either way the NFS / network file system handles the overhead.

    Re-formatting HDD to ext4 or even XFS File system fixed it -- now full USB3 speed. It still transfers over network decently too.

    I'm not sure why I had that HDD formatted in NTFS -- I usually use that one as extra backup for DVD rips --in this case old TV series and if attached to Windows - I it attach it normally via a Linux VM with a Linux File system. --- must be getting old !!!!!

    Marked as solved.

    Cheers
    jimbo
      My ComputerSystem Spec


 

Related Threads
I have been playing around with windows 10 and I have found that when you do a search for a printer/scanner (Windows Search> type and select “Printers & Scanners”> Under “Add printers & Scanners Click “Add a Printer or scanner”) then when the search...
So, recently, my Windows 10 Pro Laptop starts randomly shutting off the WiFi. I go into "Network Adapters" and my computer cut my WiFi to host a network called Direct-iGE5msPN. It often changes names so that's why I put x's in the title. Do I have a...
Hello. I installed a HP printer model M402dw and turned on WiFi Direct mode. I am able to connect to the printer enough to see it in the WiFi connections list as well as in Available Devices when I try to Add Printer. I am able to add the...
Update: see iperf tests below. Issue appears to be OS-related. No speed problems on Linux boxes, Windows causes upload slowdown. Issue: using local gigabit network uploads peak at 7-10MB/s while downloads fully saturate the link at 110MB/s. This...
I have been unable to do a direct cable connect. Settings are not available. In settings, to do a cable connect it asks for a name and ISP. There isn't any. I never had a problem doing this before and I can do it with my apple computer. It has...
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

© Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 00:36.
Find Us