1.    29 Jul 2017 #1

    Windows Networking -- Mega flaw here

    Hi there
    I know this is how windows is SUPPOSED to work but it's a real pain

    1) I have a network server with a load of HDD's on it.
    2) I allow Windows shared access to say drive HDD1 (multi-media) mounted as drive X .
    3) A smart TV can see the Windows machine but can't access or even see drive X. Seems that remote computers can only access locally attached drives to the windows machine (or locally attached USB devices).

    I don't want to allow smart TV direct access to drives on the Network server - the windows machine should be able to allow access to other machines from its own shared resources.

    Ok I know most people wouldn't try and "indirectly" share drives - but why not - if the device is shareable then it should be "seeable" from other computers too by simply looking at the relevant computer with the shared drive.

      My ComputerSystem Spec
  2.    01 Aug 2017 #2
    Join Date : Aug 2015
    Posts : 369
    Windows 10 Pro

    Quote Originally Posted by jimbo45 View Post
    I don't want to allow smart TV direct access to drives on the Network server - the windows machine should be able to allow access to other machines from its own shared resources.
    Not necessarily. What makes you believe that such "transitive" sharing should be permitted?

    Ability to access restricted resources of the network server is the privilege the server issues to its selected clients. It is a matter of server's decision: which clients should be allowed access to which resources.

    Just because server decided to give such access privilege to a specific client does not mean that server wanted to permit this client to distribute this privilege further to whoever/whatever that client pleases. That would constitute a rather loose approach to access control.

    Of course, if you really really really want to set up your local network's access control in that way - then you might want to have it in Windows, as an option (!). But it is definitely not acceptable as a default access privilege distribution model. So your claim that it "should" work that way and/or that it is somehow "natural" does not hold water. "Mega flaw"? Not really.
    Last edited by AndreyT; 01 Aug 2017 at 22:40.
      My ComputerSystem Spec
  3.    02 Aug 2017 #3

    Hi there


    Reading your post made a lot of sense actually -- I've set the server up properly now -- definitely the best way,

    Thanks for a clear and very sensible reply

      My ComputerSystem Spec


Similar Threads
Thread Forum
Mega prase from me for a WINDOWS app !!!
Hi there I've long had problems with Windows playing (or not playing) all sorts of files but I've finally run into a DECENT standard Windows App (installed with system as default) the Films and TV program - even VLC won't play some files I have....
Software and Apps
Networking Issues, What Are My Windows 10 Networking Credentials?
Ok, just upgraded to Windows 10 this week and been bashing my head bloody for two days on networking issues. What on the green Earth are my networking credentials in Win10? I have a Microsoft account I'm logging into Win10 pc with (which I hate but...
Network and Sharing
Networking doesnt work when using Safe Mode with Networking
I know I am getting on everyone's nerves with all of these posts, but this is my only way to get things resolved. Safe Mode with Networking: Networking doesn't work. Any help or suggestions would be appreciated!
Network and Sharing
host networking working in only safe mode with networking
My windows 2003 server stopped working in normal mode, but working in "safe mode with networking" and giving reply from all peers, and reaching all remote locations. in Normal mode not even ping to peer and giving error "destination host...
Network and Sharing
Mega annoying fault (all Windows not just W10)
Hi there I seem to have a really annoying fault on ANY windows OS (doesn't happen on Linux). Sometimes the HDD's seem to be "quiesced" and if say I use Windows explorer it takes (or seems to take) ages for the program to work (or any other...
General Support
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

© Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:02.
Find Us
Twitter Facebook Google+ Ten Forums iOS App Ten Forums Android App

Windows 10 Forums