Windows 10: Networking Gurus -- 4 computers - better via Wifi or use LAN bridge

  1.    24 Oct 2016 #1

    Networking Gurus -- 4 computers - better via Wifi or use LAN bridge


    Hi there

    seems difficult to find a decent answer to this - but say you have 4 laptop users on your local LAN - is it better for throughput to just let them use wifi cards in their computers or connect the 4 computers to a fast router used as an ethernet-->wifi bridge.

    The Bridge method seems to give more throughput - obviously people transferring several GB sized files over this type of arrangement will kill it but this happens very rarely.

    The advantage of the Bridge also allows the computers that can't handle 5GHZ wifi to be connected to the router using 5GHZ and a router is generally full duplex while wifi cards --certainly the cheaper end of the market are generally half duplex.

    Full blown LAN is obviously the best but I can't run loads of 1Gib/s Lan cable all over the place.

    very difficult to get any serious info on this without going up into the hideously expensive world of Enterprise gear used by large server farms etc.

    Cheers
    jimbo
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  2.    24 Oct 2016 #2

    Hi jimbo45,
    In a 1Gbps LAN the transfer speed will be 125MB/s, in full-duplex , both ends will achieve that speed.
    When sending from LAN to WLAN, the speed will be cut down by the RTS/CTS protocol and both ends will have the speed that WLAN allows. WLAN 866Mbps will allow a max of 72MB/s.

    Regarding the Bridge, Bridging means that you putting 2 or more IP Segments together, so you allow LAN and WLAN to communicate between them, without that it would not be possible to send files from 1 PC in LAN and to another on WLAN.
    Bridging does not mean that the information is being sendet simultaneously in both Channels at the same time. That would be called "Channel Bundling" and so far I know it was possible with certain Phone Lines, putting Channel A together with Channel B was doubling speed.
    So, regarding costs and speed, LAN has advantage over WLAN.
      My ComputerSystem Spec


  3. Posts : 3,438
    EL Capitan
       25 Oct 2016 #3

    You know my setup in what I am doing on my network. The only thing I have wired is the Synology NAS. If I decide to put back online the Pi's or desktops that I use for servers for testing, those go wired at the gear downstairs.

    I am running Wireless-ac with a Engenius EAP1750H The Windows 10 laptop and my Macbook are showing 867mbps connection to the A/P.

    I have six runs of Cat-5e in my house. Only using four of them at this time. Two for the A/P's and one for the Channel Master OTA tuner, the other for the NVidia shield. It came out around 200' when I pulled those lines.

    If I switch to my Engenius ECB350 and walk about 150 feet from my house, I still get close to 8mbps down with Wireless-n.
      My ComputerSystem Spec


 

Related Threads
Hi there If you've a spare / old router which you can set up as a wifi bridge and connect a bit of LAN cable from Laptop into the Bridge router you'll generally get FAR better performance from even a cheap router. Logic behind this is that...
Hi there I don't like a load of LAN cables everywhere and "She who must be obeyed" was complaining about number of boxes / gadgets / flashing lights etc under the TV !!!!!! so I've moved the two servers out of the way and just have the cable...
Solved Problem Networking Two Computers in Network and Sharing
I am having problems with Networking 2 Windows 10 computers. The first computer is an HP Laptop with windows 10 factory installed. It connects to my router via a wireless connection. The second is a Dell Desktop with 2 SSD's -- one containing...
Dear all, Can anyone advise me on a mixed network issue. I have several PCs at home as well as music streaming devices such as Pure Sensia and Freecom MusicPal. The PCs run a mix of Windows 7 HP and Ultimate all 64bit. I use Serviio to share...
how do i activate the wifi. when i click on the icon on the bottom right it doesnt bring up the connections, like it did in windows 8.1/8
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:56.
Find Us