Confused by dual search functions?

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
  1. Trust_No1's Avatar
    Posts : 596
       #1

    Confused by dual search functions?


    What is the difference in the search functions?
    you have search permanently docked on the Taskbar
    and then search permanently set in the Start Menu

    so, why are there 2 searchers (one right under the other)? Do they do different things?
      My Computer

  2. paulsalter's Avatar
    Posts : 22,962
    Windows 10
       #2

    From what I gather the one in the taskbar is going to be for Cortana (not yet active)
    The other is the normal search

    Windows 10 Cortana Information Leaks - Softpedia
      My Computer

  3. Trust_No1's Avatar
    Posts : 596
    Thread Starter
       #3

    paulsalter said:
    From what I gather the one in the taskbar is going to be for Cortana (not yet active)
    The other is the normal search

    Windows 10 Cortana Information Leaks - Softpedia
    Umm, okay

    but that still doesn't make sense to me.
    Even when Cortana is activated, wouldn't it still be part of normal searching?
      My Computer

  4. JDobbsy1987's Avatar
    Posts : 1,413
    Windows 10 Pro x64
       #4

    Trust_No1 said:
    Umm, okay

    but that still doesn't make sense to me, even when Cortana is activated, wouldn't it still be part of normal searching?
    A bit of give and take in my opinion... on a desktop i would say no but tablet/phone then maybe yes, having it right there on the task bar means it's at the touch of a finger which is what it's all about.

    Clicking start isn't exactly the long way but it is one extra click/touch
      My Computer

  5. Edwin's Avatar
    Posts : 15,439
    Windows 10
       #5

    The Charms Bar/Search Panel, Start Menu Search and the Taskbar Search all function the same with the integrated Bing thing; the taskbar icon is where you can access settings and I've got a feeling that's where 'Cortana' is going to ('talk to you') from, , and raise notifications possibly.

    https://www.tenforums.com/software-an...tml#post151423

    The integrated Bing thing creeps me out! I don't want my personal files cached online!
    The PC, ("Public Computer"), as we knew it ain't so "Personal" anymore!
    Last edited by Edwin; 06 Oct 2014 at 13:56.
      My Computer


  6. Posts : 5,834
    Dual boot Windows 10 FCU Pro x 64 & current Insider 10 Pro
       #6

    I've not a chance to install 10 yet due to faulty PSU. Awaiting shipment.

    Questions > Is there an option as to where to search in either the Start Menu or opening the one on the Taskbar? Is there still an option to turn Bing off in the Search category in PC options as in 8.x? One can opt out of things like advertising, location, and other Bing entities in 8.x. Still hold true in 10?

    I would think both searches are the same Bing integrated. The search eyeglass on the Taskbar actually mimics the one on the Start Screen. The search in 8.x was very much improved. Did much experimenting with it finding files and words within files even if the file is open. It didn't skip a beat.

    Edwin, your files won't be cached online. The only thing would be is the files you might place in OneDrive. All in all you can make your PC as private as you want. I see one can continue to use local accounts. MS is not the "evil empire" as some claim. They would get their butts sued for sure.
      My Computers


  7. Edwin's Avatar
    Posts : 15,439
    Windows 10
       #7

    HippsieGypsie said:
    Edwin, your files won't be cached online. The only thing would be is the files you might place in OneDrive. All in all you can make your PC as private as you want. I see one can continue to use local accounts. MS is not the "evil empire" as some claim. They would get their butts sued for sure.
    K, I hear ya, but, I'm skeptical.
    If you get up running with WTP, do one thing for me:
    Put something 'sacred' in your default Pictures folder, then search Pictures with that engine. When the Bing interface comes up, click on the 'Files' link in the menu bar; notice your content is displayed within that live application!
    Now, when that application is running in it's container on your PC, is the content restricted to your PC only, even though it has a ton of other content and other links displayed along side of it?
    All the content runs within that container, web or native! I'm sure personal content is not going out live over the world wide web but, I'm sure it's being cached somewhere! That's a huge privacy concern for for tons of people!

    Here's a little 'diddy' as an example, (use caution, it could be shocking!):

    Creepy but Funny - Edwin000's library
    Last edited by Edwin; 07 Oct 2014 at 13:30.
      My Computer


  8. Posts : 5,834
    Dual boot Windows 10 FCU Pro x 64 & current Insider 10 Pro
       #8

    Edwin said:
    K, I hear ya, but, I'm skeptical.
    If you get up running with WTP, do one thing for me:
    LOL! This is frustrating for me. There I was happily downloaded the WTP and attempting to burn it, then bam! Stopped cold! I'm grateful, but I've borrowed my daughter's lappy with 7 on it, so I have no 8 nor 10.

    Put something 'scared' in your default Pictures folder, then search Pictures with that engine. When the Bing interface comes up, click on the 'Files' link in the menu bar; notice your content is displayed within that live application!
    Not to point out an error, but did you mean "sacred"?

    Now, when that application is running in it's container on your PC, is the content restricted to your PC only, even though it has a ton of other content and other links displayed along side of it?
    All the content runs within that container, web or native! I'm sure personal content is not going out live over the world wide web but, I'm sure it's being cached somewhere! That's a huge privacy concern for for tons of people!
    Here's a little 'diddy' as an example, (use caution, it could be shocking!):
    Creepy but Funny - Edwin000's library
    Nice video with great music there, Edwin!

    I see they inproved the Search results interface. It's more like a in-house web page than in 8.x. I think they use HTML 5 Javascript to create these pages as they did in 8.x. HTML 5 Javascript - Windows 8.1

    Not a coder, so I wouldn't know absolutely, but I should think that it's an "in-house" (not "live") page created by using a combination of the search within File Explorer and Bing search engine. It places the results in a template. Therefore, it's an "in-house" page that's very similar to a web page, but without an address. I see it brings up ads just like a web page. The only thing that's being cached is what you're searching for, which can be opted out of along with the ads. At least in 8.x it can.

    This/these are but a few of MS's services. Don't want to use them? > Shut them off. I'm enjoying the information that 8.1 on both my PC and Lumia gives me and looking forward to it in 10. After all, this is the information age. Don't want the info? Then shut it off.

    On the other hand, I realize that this is all on by default and that it might not fit enterprise or others because of distraction. Perhaps MS should add a notice upon first boot just like the old "What's New" so to educate users on it. One could shut off "What's New" by checking "Do not show again". There was another one, but this old guy can't remember it!
      My Computers

  9. Edwin's Avatar
    Posts : 15,439
    Windows 10
       #9

    Fair enough my friend. Glad you liked the vid! Just a crazy one-off spoof but the point comes through.
    I'm by no means an expert on how all that stuff works but, I had the weirdest privacy issue with a Google application a while back so it makes me leery and cautious.
    Thanks for the feedback! :)

    (P.S. I did mean sacred; fixed!)
      My Computer


  10. Posts : 5,834
    Dual boot Windows 10 FCU Pro x 64 & current Insider 10 Pro
       #10

    Now Google is another story. What's their specialty? > Data collection for advertising initially. The Evil Mobiles they have to collect Street View data was actually collecting WiFi IP addresses to match location too. They got sued over that one. Never did follow up on that one to know the outcome. Perhaps I'll do a Bing search on it.
      My Computers


 

Related Threads
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 23:30.
Find Us




Windows 10 Forums