is 2.5 or 3.5 hard drive more durable on average?

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
  1.    #1

    is 2.5 or 3.5 hard drive more durable on average?


    Why 2.5 hard drive is usually sold at a higher price, does it mean that it's usually more durable than 3.5?

    And why for most desktop PC, they use 3.5 internal drive, I don't see any 2.5 internet drives sold in the nearby computer market. and why?
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  2.    #2

    2.5 drives are more expensive primarily due to greater manufacturing difficulty. There are differing opinions regarding reliability but likely the differences are minor. 2.5 consumer grade drives are designed primarily for laptops where a major priority is low power consumption. Everything else is a nice to have but not if it seriously compromises power consumption. 3.5 drives are available in larger capacities. For desktop use 2.5 drives have few advantages over 3.5 drives.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  3.    #3

    Generally 3.5" drives have a higher spin speed giving faster access than 2.5" drives but there are exceptions
      My ComputersSystem Spec

  4.    #4

    I guess higher spin rate = more heat produced -> more wear but I could be wrong. Of course this isn't applicable to Solid State Drives.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  5. storageman's Avatar
    Posts : 712
    Windows 10 Pro 1903 18362.239
       #5

    The cost difference is primarily caused by the media. Media of all types and sizes are never perfect ie they all have defects/bad tracks and some more that others. Since the 2.5" is quite smaller physically vs the 3.5" drives, the media needs to be more perfect for 2.5" drives vs 3.5". The yield of platters/media for larger capacity are fewer and thus will cost more.

    The same reason applies to 7200rpm vs slower drives. They cost more because they have to fly the heads closer to the media which requires a Platter surface to be smoother and less defects. Since all platters are not created equal there are fewer of them which raises the price. However platters that can't be used for 7200 drives could be used in slower drives.

    This also applies to platters/media of lower capacity which are the same as those used in higher capacity drives, but contain more defects. They are fine for the capacity of 250gb vs a 750gb.

    Bottom line is that lower capacity and slower speed drives cost much less then the higher speed/capacity drives.
      My ComputersSystem Spec

  6.    #6

    Does WD or Seagate usually make a portable drive of better quality??
      My ComputerSystem Spec


  7.    #7

    I have had good luck with Toshiba portable drives (Canvio).
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  8. thomaseg1's Avatar
    Posts : 1,284
    Windows 10 Professional (x64) Version 1903
       #8

    toshiba 64600 1 tb, workhorse for many years
      My ComputersSystem Spec


  9. Posts : 1,255
    Windows 10
       #9

    Desktop PCs use 3.5" drives as there is room in the box, power available, capacities are greater, and performance is better.

    You can put 2.5" drives in a desktop if you like, but there is no point in doing so. They are primarily for Notebooks and designed for lower power consumption and small size.

    The durability is the difference between Consumer drives and Enterprise drives which are more expensive and have longer warranties and should last longer.

    " more wear but I could be wrong. Of course this isn't applicable to Solid State Drives."

    Oh really, and what about at an atomic/molecular level with an SSD, there is wear on solid state memory cells. That is the point of TRIM and the controllers on SSDs to even out the wear on these solid state memory cells.
    Heat is also a factor in SSDs, as in all solid state devices.
      My ComputerSystem Spec

  10.    #10

    Tsw88 said: View Post
    Does WD or Seagate usually make a portable drive of better quality??
    I've had some Seagate Expansion drives for several years and they have been fine
      My ComputersSystem Spec


 
Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Related Threads
Is a 2.5 portable hard drive more durable? or is a 3.5 internal hard drive more durable? Yes, I truly know that, no matter what, any drive could fail at any time and backup is always a must. However, is there any research or statistics...
I enabled OneDrive on my computers. My main computer seemed to get slower and slower. I clicked on "This PC" and my internal drive was red - showing about 20 GB space where there had been close to 200 GB a short time before. My external...
I had to uninstall Acronis True Image 2013 which seemed to be the issue with my Windows 10 64bit PC having many BSODs. Un-installing Acronis True Image 2013 meant that I lost the use of Acronis Extended Capacity Manager to make use of all of my...
I have a hard drive off of a non-working laptop that had Windows 10 on it. I am just wanting to get some files off of the hard drive instead of repairing the laptop since it's fairly old. I have put the hard drive into a USB hard drive enclosure...
Hi! Bought a replacement secondary hard drive, but want to know best tool to clone it. My main drive is an SSD with Windows on, but I used Kari's tutorial to move the user folder on to a secondary hard drive, so just unsure on the best way to go...
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 10 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 10" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:08.
Find Us