Currently, the tutorial works just fine in all editions of Windows 10, so it's not obsolete.
I'm not sure what you mean by the tutorial not being consistent. The .reg downloads are exactly the same as what group policy sets in the registry. Both options in the tutorial are for the same settings.
I will of course test the tutorial again in all RTM editions, and make any needed updates to the tutorial at that time.
I'm not sure what you mean by the tutorial not being consistent.
Maybe I am blind, but I don't see how your screenshot shows the Disabled setting (it shows Enabled) while the text above it talks about disabling and "see screenshot below".
With this, please keep in mind that us poor users are looking for DISABLING (which you don't advise - I know) and next we're on the wrong track with selecting the Enable which your screenshot shows. It's partly a psychological thing.
That you additionally highlight (green) the text about everything but Disabling ... well, makes it only consistent with the left pane; not with the title of step 7. The Enable option does not allow anything of what that title says.
I hope it is clear now ?
PS: While we're at it anyway, it is NOT an option to state the Notify only *IF* it is the intention to not download the update anyway. I mean, you will be stuck with the message (Update available !) for the life time of the OS (you might try it on WP (8.1) for fun to see how that disturbs). So in my view, the only option available when you don't want to apply updates to begin with, is to shut it off all together (Disable in GPEdit). And that for as long as it lasts, as said.
The disabled part is in the yellow highlighted part at the top left, but the screenshot is just an example. The written steps is what is important.
Yes, I know folks want to disable, and that's why the tutorial includes a way to completely disable, and a way to notify. That way everyone can have an option for what they may want.
The purpose of notify is to let you know when you have updates available to see if you want to download and install them. If you don't then you can simply hide the update(s) (see related tutorials at bottom of tutorial) to no longer have them available and get a notification about.
Windows Updates - Hide or Show in Windows 10
Yes, I know I always recommend to install updates, but that's because you will leave Windows unpatched and more vulnerable to security risks if you don't. If you're in a situation where you can't risk updates causing an issue, then it would be best to wait a week or so after they are available before installing them. This way any unknown issues from the update at the time would be patched by then. Plus, you can also always uninstall an update if you have an issue with it.
if so did it work properly? i'm looking at using option two reg merge - thanks
Last edited by macguru; 30 Jul 2015 at 08:04.
oddly enough before I could get the updater working for win10 I had the option box 'defer upgrades'
one of the updates must have disabled that
initially updates were hanging during download - after many attempts I was finally able to get updates to completion (of particular need was the one that causes explorer to crash which I ran into immediately) - I'm not sure if the updater is buggy or if there was just too much congestion at the servers
I will monitor the system to see if this new setting might mysteriously take effect later as one poster noted happened on his machine
thanks again shawn for the excellent work!
Last edited by macguru; 30 Jul 2015 at 12:09.
Yep, it still works for me.
When you tested yours did you update to the rollout build 10240 and then run your mod or did you update to the latest build and see that it was still there? Maybe upon updating the build it still works if previously set (if that is what you did). The other situation may be that you're running something higher than Home release which allows group policy edit. I'm not familiar with how that is parsed or not if there is no local group policy installed but the registry has modded entries I suppose they are just ignored? I saw a few posts elsewhere on how to install group policy on 8, 7 perhaps I can look into setting that up and see if it would allow your workaround to be implemented. Most importantly which version are you running this on ? Home, Pro, Enterprise?
Did anyone here get this method to work on Home by any chance and if so how?
Thanks in advance!
Update : Shawn I see from your post above "Currently, the tutorial works just fine in all editions of Windows 10, so it's not obsolete." So apparently you had this working with Home edition but how ? With option 2? Have you tried it specifically with 10240 Home build as yet? Any ideas I can try? Thanks again!
Windows 10 Home users would have to use OPTION TWO in the tutorial since it doesn't include group policy.
If you have the red "some settings are managed by your organization" message in advanced options, then it worked.
The "Available updates will be downloaded and installed automatically." message you see in Windows Update is just a generic note, and is not what determines if the setting worked.