New
#21
How did you install it? With the disc or a download from HP?
My suggestion was to let Windows provide the driver - I can't tell where the driver came from.
The other point of failure might be in the spooler - is there any in the print queue?
If that is the cause, events should be logged - check event viewer (an easy way to do this is to look at properties in Device Manager - there should be an events tab)
MoxieMomma mentioned AV products and you said that you disabled ESET. It isn't enough to just disable ESET, you have to uninstall it (there were also two registry keys involved at one point, but that was a while ago and I can't locate a reference). I'm not sure if ESET is the cause, but there are known issues with ESET and many other AV products. The common resolution to the known issues is to install an upgraded version of the product using the vendor's prescribed method.
See: ESET Products compatibility with Windows 10
It's a bit tangled, but if you read enough on the ESET support pages you'll see that they recommend uninstalling the existing product before installing the upgraded product.
See: ESET KB: How do I uninstall or reinstall ESET Smart Security/ESET NOD32 Antivirus?
I go one step further and suggest that after uninstalling through Features and Programs, people use the ESET Uninstaller to clean up any residual pieces. Most vendors reserve their tool for problematic uninstalls. I suggest it because of that (the tool knows what areas might cause issues and fixes them) which might prevent problems down the line.
ESET KB: How do I manually uninstall my Windows ESET product?